September Isn’t a Fresh Start for Everyone

September has arrived, and if you’re anything like me, you may have spent the last few days feeling as though you’re supposed to suddenly have your life together.

The kids are going back to school. Summer Fridays are disappearing. Lunches need to be packed. Bedtimes need to happen at something resembling a reasonable hour. There are forms to fill out, schedules to coordinate, appointments to remember, activities to sign up for, and approximately 47 emails from schools, daycare providers, sports teams, and various organizations that all seem to require an answer right now.

And somewhere in the middle of all that, there’s this persistent cultural message that September is supposed to be a fresh start.

New routines, new goals, new habits, back to business.

Maybe I’m just tired, but I find myself wondering: does anyone actually need another fresh start?

The September reset

The more I think about it, the more I realize September feels like a second January.

January gets all the attention, of course. We make resolutions, buy leather-bound planners on Etsy, and promise ourselves that this will finally be the year we exercise regularly, eat better, organize the basement, call our mothers more often, and stop leaving everything until the last possible minute.

Then September comes along and gives us another opportunity to try again.

And I understand why. There really is something satisfying about a new beginning. After the looseness of summer, routines can feel comforting, and there’s a certain pleasure in knowing what time everyone needs to leave the house, when dinner is happening, and approximately how many minutes we have before someone announces that they’ve lost a shoe.

But somewhere along the way, “getting back into a routine” seems to have become synonymous with getting everything under control.

And, at least in my experience, those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

Routines can be genuinely helpful, especially for kids. Knowing what comes next can make days feel more predictable and give everyone a bit more stability when the rest of life is in constant flux.

But a routine doesn’t need to be perfect to be useful, and September probably isn’t the best month to judge how well yours is working anyway.

Transitions are harder than they look

One thing I’ve been thinking about lately is just how much change gets packed into this seemingly ordinary month.

For children, September can mean a new classroom, a new teacher, a new school, new classmates, new expectations, and sometimes a completely different daily rhythm. For parents, it can mean trying to coordinate all of those moving pieces while continuing to work, manage a household, care for other family members, and somehow remember that Wednesday is library day.

And for some families, September brings much bigger changes. A child might be starting school for the first time, an older child might be leaving home, or a family may be adjusting to a new job, a separation, a move, financial changes, or a new caregiving responsibility.

Even happy changes can be stressful.

That’s something we maybe don’t talk about enough. We tend to think of stress as a sign that something has gone wrong, but transitions themselves require energy. Our brains and bodies have to adjust to new circumstances, even when those circumstances are things we’ve been looking forward to.

Good enough is still good

I think this is where the pressure to have a “good routine” can get a little ridiculous.

There are endless articles telling us how to create the perfect morning routine, the perfect bedtime routine, the perfect homework routine, and the perfect family schedule. Some of those ideas are actually helpful, but there’s a point where family life starts to sound less like family life and more like one enormous productivity project.

Some mornings will run smoothly. Other mornings, everyone will be late, somebody will forget their lunch, and you’ll spend ten minutes looking for a water bottle that is literally in your hand.

I suspect both mornings count.

Maybe the goal of a routine isn’t to make family life perfectly predictable. Maybe it’s simply to give the week enough structure that everyone roughly knows where they’re supposed to be, what happens next, and when they can finally take their shoes off.

That leaves room for plans to change, for people to be tired, and for Tuesday dinner to bear very little resemblance to whatever ambitious meal you had imagined on Sunday afternoon.

A family can have rhythm without running like clockwork.

What was already working?

There’s another reason I’m a little suspicious of the idea of a September “reset.”

Starting over sounds wonderful until you realize that it quietly suggests whatever came before wasn’t quite good enough.

Perhaps summer didn’t go exactly as planned. Or the kids spent more time on screens than you intended. Or the house is still a mess. Or there are things you meant to sort out in June that remain stubbornly unsorted in September.

I have no idea why a new page on the calendar should suddenly require us to answer for any of that.

Instead of asking, What do we need to change?, September gives us a chance to ask something slightly kinder: What was already working?

What made the mornings easier? What helped everyone feel connected? What parts of summer do we actually want to carry with us, and what can we stop doing simply because it never worked very well in the first place?

That seems more useful to me than starting over. It’s less dramatic, admittedly. Nobody has ever sold many planners under the slogan Continue doing several things that appear to be working reasonably well.

But families probably don’t need reinvention nearly as often as we’re told they do.

September doesn’t have to be a test

I suppose that’s what I’m really trying to say.

You don’t have to emerge from the first week of school with a colour-coded calendar, a spotless house, a perfectly organized lunch station, and a renewed commitment to becoming the best possible version of yourself.

You can just be a family figuring things out.

There will be good days and chaotic ones. There will be forgotten permission slips, last-minute grocery runs, and mornings when everyone is somehow in a remarkably good mood for reasons that remain completely mysterious.

There will also be those little moments when you realize that things are beginning to settle into place.

Jessica Price, coordinator, Family Matters / Coordonnatrice, Famille – Petite enfance

So if things still feel scattered right now, give yourselves some time. Eventually, the mornings will become easier, packing lunches will require less thought, and someone will find the missing shoe.

And in the meantime, there’s no prize for getting September exactly right.

 Hugs,

Jessica

Scroll to Top